It seems to me that the effort here is to imagine that the dephysicalization that afflicts the Fourth Amendment can be reversed. Changing the physical "community" changes power relationships, of course. Changing who hires and manages police affects policing, also of course. The idea of Black communities reversing the constitutionalism of white supremacy that denies Black rights is as old as enslavement itself.

But the society of persistent interconnection, the condition we call "the Internet," by changing the meanings of search, seizure, persons and effects, by dephysicalizing what we search for and how we search for it, has also blunted the difference between places "we" control and places "they" police. Whether to have red light cameras, or body cameras on police, or "gunshot microphones" in town is decided mostly by whose town it is. But the surveillance of cashless spending, or predictive modeling based on consumer data, or state-level efforts to prohibit abortion services, etc. will not necessarily be affected by who controls the town council or hires the police chief.

So it seems to me that the way to make this essay better is to be clearer about the Fourth Amendment's "localism," about how we think of surveillance in law enforcement and its regulation, not by evidentiary rules of a constitutional dimension, but the practices and behaviors of the "community," writ large and well as small, and what we can expect from municipalities.

Sanctuaries of Sovereignty: Redefining Surveillance, Security, and Community for Black Americans"

-- By TristonFerguson - 02 May 2024

The past year has presented me with the opportunity to explore the potential benefits of creating communities and neighborhoods, similar to Martha’s Vineyard or Sag Harbor. I hope to continue learning more about these communities and the reasons for their existence. Moreover, This essay will serve as a proxy for a project I would like to accomplish at some point in my life. Specifically, I will explore the intersection of the 4th Amendment and surveillance of Black people, and consider the potential benefits of creating communities akin to Martha's Vineyard or Sag Harbor as a means to reduce surveillance and foster comfort.

In the United States, the 4th Amendment to the Constitution guarantees the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, without probable cause and a warrant issued by a judge. However, the reality for many people of color in America has been marked by disproportionate surveillance and policing, which infringes upon constitutional protections. My initial interest in the notion of over surveillance was sparked last semester when my class group worked on a project that explored the #notechforice campaign, which exposed data companies such as Lexusnexis, and their unethical practices of selling data to ICE to aid in surveilling and deporting people of color. Through this project, I began to further understand the need and desire to develop strong communities of color where these types of issues are no longer prevalent.

The issue of surveillance of people of color, primarily black individuals dates back to systemic racism and historical injustices perpetrated against African Americans. From the era of slavery to the Civil Rights Movement and beyond, people of color and their communities have faced heightened scrutiny and monitoring by law enforcement agencies and government entities. This phenomenon reflects broader societal biases and structural inequalities that persist in America. One of the key challenges associated with the surveillance of Black people is the tendency for law enforcement to engage in racial profiling. This practice often involves targeting individuals based on race rather than reasonable suspicion or specific evidence of criminal activity. As a result, people of color are disproportionately subjected to unethical and invasive surveillance tactics, which include stop-and-frisk policies, electronic surveillance, and data collection through various technologies. I would argue that the impact of surveillance on people of color extends beyond mere inconvenience; it undermines trust in law enforcement and perpetuates feelings of fear and alienation from their white counterparts. The constant scrutiny and suspicion faced by people of color contribute to a sense of being constantly under surveillance, even in everyday activities. This pervasive surveillance not only violates the spirit of the 4th Amendment but also perpetuates a cycle of distrust between communities of color and law enforcement agencies.

I believe that these issues can be adequately addressed through the creation communities similar to Martha's Vineyard or Sag Harbor offers an intriguing possibility. These communities are known for their exclusivity and privacy, attracting affluent residents seeking seclusion and comfort. By establishing similar communities that prioritize privacy and limit external surveillance, there is potential to create environments where Black residents can feel safe and protected from unwarranted monitoring. In Martha's Vineyard and Sag Harbor, residents and visitors can enjoy a sense of security and insulation from the outside world (for the most part). The privacy afforded by these communities allows individuals to live without constant surveillance, fostering a greater sense of comfort, autonomy and safety. Importantly, such environments demonstrate the possibility of living free from law enforcement and societal judgment. However, it is important to note that the lack of law enforcement isn't because these places are secluded. In my opinion, it is because they are popular places known to host affluent people of color.

The establishment of similar communities for Black residents could serve as a sanctuary from systemic surveillance and racial profiling. By controlling access and promoting privacy within these enclaves, residents would have greater control over their personal information and movements. This control is crucial in combating the erosion of privacy rights experienced by many Black Americans. Furthermore, creating exclusive communities for Black residents could contribute to broader social and cultural empowerment. By cultivating spaces where Black culture thrives and where residents feel protected, these communities can serve as centers of resilience and resistance against oppressive surveillance practices. They could also become hubs for social activism and community organizing, empowering residents to advocate for systemic change.

Furthermore, the 4th Amendment's protections against unreasonable searches and seizures must be upheld for all Americans, including Black communities who have historically faced disproportionate surveillance and policing. The creation of communities similar to Martha's Vineyard or Sag Harbor represents a potential solution to reducing surveillance and fostering comfort for Black residents. These communities can provide sanctuary from invasive monitoring and contribute to the empowerment and resilience of Black individuals and communities. Ultimately, ensuring the privacy and security of Black Americans is essential for upholding their constitutional rights and achieving greater social justice in our society. In my next essay, I will discuss areas and opportunities where communities similar to Sag Harbor and Marthas’s Vineyard can exist, and how they can best be developed. However, I will need to understand the desire for black prosperity and progress, and the type of people these communities would likely attract. Additionally, I will need to explore alternatives to traditional methods of surveillance to ensure the community remains safe. I believe that a system of trust can be developed within these communities and it is very likely that this would be sufficient to hold everyone accountable. It is possible that this can be coupled with some form of technology, but it may not be necessary. Regardless, I believe that is something worth exploring.

• #Set ALLOWTOPICVIEW = TWikiAdminGroup, TristonFerguson
• #Set DENYTOPICVIEW = TWikiGuest

Note: TWiki has strict formatting rules for preference declarations. Make sure you preserve the three spaces, asterisk, and extra space at the beginning of these lines. If you wish to give access to any other users simply add them to the comma separated ALLOWTOPICVIEW list.