|
>
> |
| META TOPICPARENT | name="FirstPaper" |
|---|
Recognizing Chance to Become Better Lawyers
-- By EllaAiken - 27 Feb 2009
Introduction
The idea that we have “won the lottery” through our circumstances of birth has come up, and we have questioned where we go from here. I’d like to explore further how that can and should impact our future legal career and how it can help us be better advocates for our clients.
Acknowledging that we were blessed to be born into the conditions we were—and I think this goes for anyone who is now at Columbia, because even if you were born poor and underprivileged, those are relative classifications—only takes us part of the way. We can realize that we may not have been given all of the opportunities that were open us, by chance or mistake. But we should also realize that, but for a chance in circumstances, we could have made the very same mistakes that our clients made, regardless of how grim.
An obligation in work
Once we realize that we have a rare opportunity in front of us, it becomes incumbent upon us to take our license and do good in the world. The good need not necessarily be working a low paying public interest job. Robinson appeared to be one of the “good guys,” even if he was representing society’s bad guys. What made him good was that he chose his clients (they could not necessarily simply choose him by forking over a small fee) and that he advocated for them. Professor Moglen shared an encounter with us about the lawyer on the Court House steps who had received his fee and seem little bothered that his client would nonetheless be serving a life-term, indeed, he said it would do him some good. While he and Robinson may have both been criminal defense lawyers, Robinson appears to still be one of the good guys, and the other lawyer a bad guy. I am not suggesting that we need to care passionately about the fate of our more-than-likely very guilty clients, but complete apathy is inappropriate—we need to care about their fate, even if we are unable to think that the outcome was necessarily wrong. If we appreciate the chance of our position, then perhaps we can be more open to the situation and needs of our clients.
Understanding & Advocacy
Jessica Lenahan, formerly Jessica Gonzales, spoke at a law school lunch last month. (If you are unfamiliar with her tragedy, find more information here). She asked all of us to remember as we embark into the legal profession that we need clients just as much as clients need lawyers. She expressed frustration at lawyers in the past had not taken the time to explain the progress of her case or its nuances to her, and asked us to remember not only that we need each other, but that we could be each other.
If we take the concept of the lottery to heart, then we must realize that we could easily be the person seeking some form of justice for a life-shattering event. If her lawyers had considered the amount of information and the level of detail we would want had we been born into her life, perhaps they would take more time to go over the details. I realize that we are not psychologists, and that it may seem unnecessary to explain every legal detail to a client, but if we could put ourselves in the position of our clients, we could understand their desire to know all the legal details.
Realizing how mostly chance separates us from our clients would not only be good for our clients, but that it would in turn make us better advocates. I have often heard that a good legal advocate is passionate about their cause. If we understand just how close we may be to our clients’ situations, then we may be able to feel and express more passion in our advocacy.
Between Here and Rikers Island
Maybe we will be able to sympathize with clients like Lenahan, and realize that we could be in their shoes, but it may be harder for us to do this when the client is not the victim but the perpetrator. Yet once again, we must recognize that born under different conditions, we could make similar mistakes as many, though maybe not all, of the population of Rikers. Most of us have probably grown up thinking of inmates as bad-guys, and deserving of their incarceration. This may be true to an extent—I have gone through the Sunday morning visitation line and held no wish that the visit could be held in the world of the free—but this does not mean that, given a different set of circumstances, I could have made mistakes that many others have made, or that inmates could not in another world be lawyers.
Robinson plays with the idea of lawyers and prisoners transforming into each other. He seems to toy play with the fact that the lawyers and prisoners are not that different from each other. Perhaps the realization that not much separates us from them other than circumstance is part of what makes him a good guy, and the lawyer on the courthouse steps a bad guy. We as lawyers must recognize that we may be the last barrier before stepping onto that island. If we recognize the dumb luck of it all, perhaps we will take this role as barrier more seriously, more compassionately, and with the greatest interests of our clients at heart.
In the end, I think that the kind of law that we choose to pursue is less indicative of appreciating our opportunity than the way in which we practice it. Certainly some kind of lawyering may be inherently an offence against such a realization. But beyond that, whether we are criminal defense attorneys, prosecutors, or whether we deal with wills and trusts, understanding how easily we might be in the chair facing us may make us stronger lawyers, better advocates, and good people.
You are entitled to restrict access to your paper if you want to. But we all derive immense benefit from reading one another's work, and I hope you won't feel the need unless the subject matter is personal and its disclosure would be harmful or undesirable.
To restrict access to your paper simply delete the "#" on the next line:
# * Set ALLOWTOPICVIEW = TWikiAdminGroup, EllaAiken
Notelink text? : TWiki has strict formatting rules. Make sure you preserve the three spaces, asterisk, and extra space at the beginning of that line. If you wish to give access to any other users simply add them to the comma separated list |
|